Heidi Schmutz
English 2010 M & W
06/29/2009
John Q and Heart Transplants
Each year thousands of adults in the United States would be saved if they were able to get a donated heart transplant. More than 2,200 heart transplants were performed last year in the United States alone. When the heart no longer can adequately work and a person is at risk of dying, a heart transplant may be indicated. It involves removing a diseased heart and replacing it with a healty human heart. Cardiac transplantation is recognized to be a proven procedure in appropriately selected patients (Heart). John Q is a movie that shows the problem many Americans have with getting proper health care. The producers of the movie show America’s health care problems by showing a boy who needs a heart transplant, and a father that will do anything to help his son get the help his son needs.
John Q is a movie based off of the trouble a man goes through to get health care for his son when he doesn’t have any insurance. Denzel Washington plays John Q. Archibald in the movie. Mr. Archibald is a factory worker that is having financial hardship because of the his cut back hours. The family is struggling when their son becomes terminally ill with heart failure. While the Archibalds have health insurance they are informed by the hospital administrator Rebbeca Payne, played by Anne Heche, that their health insurance doesn’t cover such an expensive procedure. As John Q. tries to raise the money himself he soon finds that there is no hope so he has to take his soon out of the hospital to die. John Q. snapped and decided that if he couldn’t raise the money the right way that he would force the doctors to operate on his son. He held the hospital hostige until somebody was able to give a heart transplant and the doctors operated (Williams). John Q Archibald is a desperate parent in the movie that knows he will only be able to get his son help by forcing the hospital to operate on him. This shows what many Americans face today.
In addition because of the great need for heart transplants, and the fact that it is a dangerous procedure, many people get screened out. The only patients that are able to have a heart transplants are the ones that have tried everything else and are sick enough to get one, but healthy enough to take the procedure. Since the heart transplant is the last result many doctors will try to do everything before issuing the need for a heart transplant. Although this screens out many people the patients that do receive the heart transplant do not have a very good life expectancy after 10-20 years (What). This shows that even though many people may need a heart transplant many doctors are not willing to do the procedure, and therefore the patient may die because of that small fact.
Some may say that John Q is an over exaggeration of what might happen if a desperate parent needs to get help for his son, and that there are many flaws to thinking that he can take hostage a hospital, but one has to think that if they were in John Q shoes what would be going through their minds at the time. The movie although dramatized depicts the problems that many Americans face not only with heart transplants but with many other health care issues. In some way people have to believe that there is a better way. When you watch a young child die because his parents don’t have enough health insurance to cover the cost of a surgery, one must think that the most valueable thing in that situation should be the child’s life, not the money needed to do the surgery.
"Heart Transplants: Statistics." American Heart Association. American Heart Association. 29 Jun 2009
.
Williams, Karl. "John Q Summary." Starplus.com. 27 Jun 2009 .
"What is a Heart Transplant?." Heart and Vascular Diseases. Sep 2009. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. 29 Jun 2009 .